Best Italian Food in Northeast Florida

When it comes to Italian restaurants in Florida, the options may seem overwhelming. However, it is important to remember that quality surpasses quantity. Jacksonville, St. Augustine, Palm Coast, and Amelia Island areas boast some of the top Italian restaurants in the sunshine state. From the classic flavors of pizza, calzones, spaghetti, and lasagna, to lesser known dishes that are sure to tantalize your taste buds, these cities have it all. But don't be fooled by size - even smaller cities such as Taylor, Macclenny, Green Cove Springs, Middleburg, Ponte Vedra, Palatka, Satsuma, and Orange Park have hidden gems waiting to be discovered. Indulge in the rich and authentic flavors of Italy right here in the beautiful sunshine state. No need to book a flight to Europe when the best Italian cuisine can be found right in your own backyard. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you.

Where are you?

Where do you want to go?
baker County
Cities & Communities: Baxter, Cuyler, Glen Saint Mary, Macclenny, Macedonia, Margeretta, Olustee, Sanderson, and Taylor.
We are still looking for the best Italian restaurant in Baker County. If you know who it is, let us know!
nassau County
Cities & Communities: Amelia City, Amelia Island, American Beach, Bryceville, Callahan, Crawford, Dyal, Evergreen, Fernandina Beach, Franklintown, Hilliard Kent, Lessie, Nassauville, O'Neil and Yulee.
Moon River Pizza - Website925 S 14th St, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034 (904) 321-3400
What makes us the best: fantastic classic pizza, salads, main pies, and bread stix
Duval County
Cities & Communities: Atlantic Beach, Baldwin, Jacksonville, Jacksonville Beach, Mayport, and Neptune Beach.
Mama's Pizza & Grill- Website9550 Baymeadows Rd, Jacksonville, FL 32256 (904) 423-1234
What makes us the best: great place to go for pizza, subs, and chicken wings
clay County
Cities & Communities: Asbury Lake, Bellair, Green Cove Springs, Keystone Heights, Lakeside, Meadowbrook Terrace, Middleburg, Orange Park, Penney Farms.
We are still looking for the best Italian restaurant in Clay County. If you know who it is, let us know!
Putnam County
Cities & Communities: Bardin, Crescent City, Fruitland, Georgetown, Hollister, Huntington, Interlachen, Lake Como, Melrose, Orange Mills, Palatka, Pomona Park, Putnam Hall, San Mateo, Satsuma, and Welaka.
We are still looking for the best Italian restaurant in Putnam County. If you know who it is, let us know!
St Johns County
Cities & Communities; Crescent Beach, Elkton, Fort Mantanzas, Fruit Cove, Hastings, Marineland, Palm Valley, Ponte Vedra, Ponte Verda Beach, St Augustine, St Augustine Beach, Switzerland, and Vilano Beach.
We are still looking for the best Italian restaurant in St Johns County. If you know who it is, let us know!
Flagler County
Cities & Communities: Beverly Beach, Bimini, Bunnell, Codys Corner, Dupont, Espanola, Favoretta, Flagler Beach, Marineland, and Palm Coast.
We are still looking for the best Italian restaurant in Clay County. If you know who it is, let us know!

Hungry for something different?

Did you know? Caesar salad is a beloved dish enjoyed by many, and it has a fascinating history that often leads to a common misconception. The question that often arises is, is Caesar salad truly an Italian dish? While it may seem to have connections to Julius Caesar himself, the truth is that it was actually created by an Italian chef named Caesar Cardini. Cardini, who owned a restaurant in Tijuana, Mexico, invented this classic salad in the early 1920s. Despite its origins in Mexico, we may not be able to credit Julius Caesar for this delicious creation, but we can thank an Italian chef for bringing it to our plates and hearts.

After all, it's all about the sunshine state

Subscribe to our newsletter
Sign up with your email address to receive news and updates.